Aug 8, 2020  •  For Sale  •  11 Comments

Stored 25 Years: 1951 Pontiac Chieftain Convertible

Disclosure: This site may receive compensation from some link clicks and purchases.

The 1949 Chieftain and Streamliner would be Pontiac’s first new designs since the end of World War II. The former would be the entry level model and the latter more upscale, but they shared the same new B-body and engines. It would be the first time in 15 years that all Pontiacs rode on the same wheelbase. A continuation of that new design, this 1951 Chieftain is a project car today that was purchased 25 years ago the same way. It’s been garage-kept, but some furry creatures have tried to call it home. Located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, it’s available here on eBay where eight bids have hit $4,051 with no reserve.

Pontiac’s would be a part of the product line-up for 10 years though 1958 (my folks owned one of those; what a tank it was!). Interior lighting – something you’d take for granted today – was standard equipment in these cars. Before they were known as the “wide-track” people, Pontiac would come up with little creature comforts that other car makers might not offer, such as optional radios with seven vacuum tubes, a tissue dispenser, under-seat heaters and even a Remington Auto-Home shaver! The Chieftain came with such “newfangled” instruments like a gas gauge, ammeter, oil pressure gauge and temperature gauge.

The seller of this 1951 Chieftain says he bought it 25 years ago as a project that never went anywhere (I can relate). It’s not complete in that a lot of trim is missing, but there are other assorted trim pieces going with the car that may or may not fit it. Sadly, the hood ornament (which is there) is partially broken and the two-piece windshield glass is gone. The car was photographed where it sits, so what photos we do have are largely from the driver’s side. The seller doesn’t bring up the subject of rust and we don’t have much here to critique.

Pontiac engines of the day were flatheads that came in six-and eight-cylinder configurations. There is only one photo of the engine compartment and I can only count six spark plugs, but the seller says it’s an eight, so I guess the other two are more obscurely-located. Chieftains used 239 and 249 cubic-engines, putting out from 90 to 106 horsepower depending on the number of cylinders and compression. We’re told the car has an automatic tranny, but the vehicle does not run or drive and probably hasn’t since Reagan was in office.

We’re not sure how many 1951 Chieftain convertibles were built because Pontiac didn’t break out production figures by model in those days. Of 316,009 total Pontiacs made that year, some 252,000 had the automatic, so this convertible is somewhere in that second group. If someone had hermitically sealed up this car eons ago, it could maybe be worth mid-five figures today. But in its current state, the bidding may have already found the ceiling.

Comments

  1. LarryS
    Aug 8, 2020 at 5:45pm

    It’s an 8. The front 2 spark plugs are kind of hidden by the thermostat (?) housing.

    Like 16
    • piston poney
      Aug 8, 2020 at 6:02pm

      Yeah I was about say that one is and the other you can see it just has black on it and you can still see the plug wires.

      Like 4
    • Marvin Clark
      Aug 9, 2020 at 1:40pm

      Aka “Goose neck”. It is an 8.

      Like 0
  2. Skorzeny
    Aug 8, 2020 at 6:48pm

    This is a neat piece of Pontiac history, and the straight eight would be neat to experience, but I wonder if it’s just destined to be a street rod? Either way, I hope someone restores it. Can’t be too many left…

    Like 8
  3. Frank Fitz
    Aug 8, 2020 at 10:31pm

    Anatomy of a Murder starring Jimmy Stewart had the main character attorney driving a similar convertible. GLWTA

    Like 2
  4. Johnmloghry Johnmloghry
    Aug 9, 2020 at 9:46am

    It sure will need a lot of work, but it may be worth it in the end. I happen to know where a 2 door hardtop is that has all the missing pieces. Put the two together you could come up with a very nice car. I wouldn’t pay $4000.00 for both together but that’s just me.
    God bless America

    Like 1
  5. Vince H
    Aug 9, 2020 at 11:13am

    I have a friend that has a 50 convertible with the 8

    Like 2
  6. Phil
    Aug 9, 2020 at 7:37pm

    Count plug wires ……..8

    Like 0
  7. TimM
    Aug 9, 2020 at 9:12pm

    To much work to get this one into a runner!! Pass on this one!!

    Like 0
  8. Stevieg
    Aug 19, 2020 at 11:17am

    I must say I was shocked to see that here. I had actually purchased this from a friend a while back, paid him to store it until my upcoming sentence is completed. I actually bought 2 vehicles from him, flipped the other to help fund the restoration of this one.
    I just called him, it had sold. He wanted to surprise me with cash when I got out instead of a project.
    Truth is, I know & trust this guy. I believe him. His heart is in the right place.
    I told him what I sold the other car for (more than I paid for both) & told him to keep half the cash. We are both happy with that.
    Truth is, the car was not in that bad shape, but I have no experience with this vintage vehicle. I was probably in over my head, and I think my friend knew this.
    It was a very solid starting point, and I hope the buyer does something cool with it.
    I located the missing and broken components, all locally. It shouldn’t be a real difficult project for the right person. When I am released from my upcoming doom & gloom, I will move on to my 1968 Firebird convertible instead. Now I have more money for that lol.

    Like 0

Leave A Comment

RULES: No profanity, politics, or personal attacks.

Become a member to add images to your comments.

*

*

Barn Finds